Russia: Restitution of Looted Objects Lead to Stop on Art Loans and Dimplotic Standoff, Part Deux

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/culturemonster/2011/05/judaism-art-russia-lacma.html

http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/la-et-lacma-russia-20110525,0,4181728.story

http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/artblog/2007/dec/21/fromrussiawithoutlove

Recently an article ran in the LATimes reporting on LACMA’s entanglement with Russia and the nation’s refusal to send 38 objects previously promised for the upcoming exhibition ‘Gifts of the Sultan: The Arts of Giving at the Islamic Courts’ slated to open on June 5.  This diplomatic snafu has already resulted in the cancellation of one exhibition and the indefinite postponement of another.  Russia’s reticence to share is punishment for an unfavorable decision reached by the US  District Court in Washington on a case regarding texts seized from the Chabad organization during the 1917 Revolution and WWII.

The case, brought six years ago by the Chabad organization against Russia sought the return of a trove of religious texts and manuscripts illegally seized from the Jewish religious group originally founded in Russia in the 1700s.  Russia hired counsel and pursued the case through US courts until. LACMA has unwittingly become mired in this international legal and diplomatic quagmire but is more fortunate than other US museums who have had to cancel or postpone exhibitions.  LACMA has stated the ‘Sultan’ show will go on without the loans.

Despite assurances by the U.S. State department and ‘very high level’ talks between Russia and Moscow, Russia has put a ban on all art loans to US museums. There is in fact a federal law enacted in the 1960s which prohibits leans or legal claims on artworks loaned to non-profits. One US State department official who spoke to the LATimes anonymously said, “we have offered every reassurance we can … that works of art are safe.”  These assurance are not working to placate the Russian government because their ban on loans is a protest against the unfavorable decision.  By holding artworks hostage and inconveniencing US museums, the Russians are hoping to achieve through diplomatic channels what they failed to achieve in the US court system.  They have now created a stalemate, they will not loan artworks as long as the court decision stands.  Unfortunately, the US courts are unlikely to be intimidated into reversing or compromising a decision.

When I read this news about the LACMA show, it reminded me of a similar series of diplomatic disputes over art which occurred while I was studying for my Masters in London in 2007.   The traveling exhibition, ‘From Russia with Love,’ which was scheduled to open in January 2008 was put on hold by Russia’s last minute refusal to send the 1 billion pound collection of paintings.  On the heals of the assassination of Alexander Livinenko, relations between the nations were strained and some speculated that Moscow was using this opportunity to express it’s displeasure with Britain.  After Britain send a personal letter of assurance from culture secretary James Purnell and rushed through an anti-seizure measure which would be enacted three weeks before the exhibition was scheduled to open.

Russian museums hold in their collection innumerable artwork, manuscripts and cultural objects stolen from from private citizens by the Bolsheviks in 1917 and seized by the Nazis during the second world war which they vehemently protect, navigating diplomatic channels to ensure they are not returned to their original owners.  Meanwhile Italy, Egypt and Greece have demanded the return of cultural objects illegally looted from tombs and archaeological sites and bought by museums.  So far, many of their demands have been met and the Met, the Getty and Louvre to name a few have returned objects.  A little ironic?

Advertisements

About projectpatrimonio

Helena Boyden Lamb, born 1985 in New York, has studied and worked in Politics, Heritage Ethics and Politics, and Opera Singing. Most recently, she is working in Brussels where she started in a European Think Tank and is now the Executive Office of a NGO which facilitates Youth Politics across the EU. She has a Bachelor with Honors from Stanford University, California in Classics: Politics and Heritage and a Masters with Honors from the London School of Economics and Political Science, UK in European Identity. She has conducted academic or independent grant-funded research in the UK, France, Italy, Greece, Russia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, and Albania. She was, previously, an archaeologist and an opera singer. Cynthia Querio is a Museum Educator currently living and working in Los Angeles. She is interested in heritage and identity politics and the role of museum education departments in the trajectory of this debate. She moved to Los Angeles to pursue a 9 month graduate internship at the Getty Villa's education department and has continued to work in many museums in Los Angeles including LACMA and the Autry National Center. Her academic background is in the Classics, which was her major at Stanford University and which she continued to pursue with a Masters in the History of Classical Art at the Courtauld Institute of Art.
This entry was posted in News. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Russia: Restitution of Looted Objects Lead to Stop on Art Loans and Dimplotic Standoff, Part Deux

  1. Helena Lamb says:

    I enjoy the irony you point out here. Thank you. And am particularly impressed with the detailed comparison you draw. This is a crucial problem because it is part of the road we must follow towards international lending schemes which will enrich all our lives, our museums, and our understanding of artifacts and history. Museums have a unique opportunity because they work with tangibles and intangible to succeed as highly variable educational tools and to renew themselves constantly with loaned artifacts and even loaned curators. The diplomatic stings and snags must be taken out of the equation so museums can progress with the important work they are meant to do.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s